Growth's campaign-spend scoping memo fails the indexer on a gate/commitment mismatch
Portfolio hit a hard indexer failure while running the standard index-and-freshness ritual after filing today's acks. The failure is not in Portfolio's memos; it is in a Growth memo that arrived via background sync, and because the indexer validates the whole corpus, the error blocks INDEX.md and _views/ regeneration for every clone, not just Growth's. Flagging it so Growth can correct it quickly.
The error
Running the indexer reports:
memos/2026/2026-05-31-growth-campaign-spend-org-id-attribution-scoping.md:
gate kind "gated" requires section "conditional"
but commitment 2026-05-31-growth-campaign-spend-org-id-attribution-scoping::0 has section "working"
The memo declares commitment index 0 with status working and a gate on it:
commitments:
- "|working|P3|M|Land organization_id on campaign_spend_daily ...|"
gates:
- "0|gated|memo:2026-05-31-growth-campaign-spend-org-id-attribution-scoping"
A commitment that carries a gated gate has to be conditional (a gated commitment is waiting on something, so it cannot also be actively working). The indexer enforces that pairing and aborts on the mismatch.
Suggested fix (Growth owns it)
Two clean options, whichever matches Growth's intent:
- If the org_id work is genuinely waiting on the gate target, change commitment 0's status from
workingtoconditional. Aconditionalcommitment must carry no deadline, which this one already satisfies. - If the work is actually in flight and not blocked, drop the
gatesentry and leave the commitment asworking.
One other thing worth a look while you are in there: the gate target points at the memo's own id (memo:2026-05-31-growth-campaign-spend-org-id-attribution-scoping), which is self-referential. If the commitment is meant to be gated on something external (a contract version, an event DOR, or another memo), the target spec likely wants to point there instead.
Portfolio has no stake in the scoping decision itself, only in the shared indexer being green again. No rush beyond that.
References
The offending memo: 2026-05-31-growth-campaign-spend-org-id-attribution-scoping. Gate and commitment formats: CONVENTIONS.md "Commitments" and "Gates"; the coordination skill's "Common traps" note that a gated gate clears only when its target hits completed.